Liking a band to me boils down to:
-Talent
-Band Members
-Song Meanings
-Overall Sound
Those are the main points I look for in a band, because to me that's what music should be. They should be writing music to write music, and to enjoy the fun of that, rather than trying to become popular or anything like that. Even with popularity, it should still ultimately be the band's decision what they want to do. Now that I'm starting projects, I know that there will be stress, but that stress will usually go away if everyone just remembers the main point. Not popularity, fun! When each person can put in their opinion and not have to worry about being ripped on for it, then you really have something going. You'll notice that most popular bands nowadays get worse and worse as time goes on, and why do you think that is? Personally I think they let popularity get in the way of their main focus at the start. That's not necessarily a bad thing unless you let it be. That's about all I have today, so thanks for reading and feel free to leave a comment if you wish. I'd love to talk music anytime I can.